Departments
Departments
Departments
SlowSip
New to Slowsip? Create Account
The Irish Coffee was invented in 1943 by Joe Sheridan, head chef at the Foynes flying boat terminal on the Shannon Estuary — the transatlantic seaplane base that served as Ireland's main airport before Shannon Airport existed. A flight from Foynes to New York had turned back due to bad weather, and Sheridan was asked to prepare something to warm the cold, disappointed passengers. He added Irish whiskey to their coffee and topped it with cream. When one passenger asked if this was Brazilian coffee, Sheridan reportedly replied, 'No, that's Irish coffee.' The name and the drink have both survived intact for over eighty years, which is a considerably better track record than most cocktails invented to solve a specific and temporary problem.
What has not survived intact is the standard of execution. Most Irish Coffees served in the UK are made carelessly — instant coffee, canned cream, whiskey added without regard for proportion — which has allowed a genuinely excellent drink to develop a reputation as an afterthought. The recipe below is not complicated. It requires attention rather than skill, and the attention is worth giving.
Cream preparation (do this first):
Pour the double cream into a small bowl or jug. Whip lightly with a whisk or fork — 15 to 20 seconds is usually enough. The cream should thicken slightly and move slowly when tilted, but should still pour. It should not hold stiff peaks or stand up like whipped cream on a dessert. This is the single most common mistake in home Irish Coffee: cream whipped too far sits on top like a solid disc rather than floating and blending slightly as it's drunk through.
The drink:
Warm the glass with hot water, then discard the water.
Add the sugar to the warm glass, then pour in the hot coffee. Stir until the sugar has fully dissolved — this must happen before the whiskey goes in, or the sugar will not dissolve properly once the temperature drops slightly.
Add the whiskey and stir once, briefly, to combine.
Float the cream: hold a teaspoon curved-side up, just above the surface of the coffee, and pour the cream slowly over the back of the spoon so it spreads and settles on top rather than sinking in. Done correctly the cream should sit as a distinct pale layer on top of the dark coffee beneath, with a clean line between the two.
Do not stir after adding the cream. The drink is meant to be drunk through the cream layer — the coffee and whiskey hot underneath, the cream cold and rich on the lips. Stirring it together defeats the point of the technique entirely.
On the float — why it matters and how to actually do it
The floated cream is not a decorative flourish; it is the entire structural idea of the drink. An Irish Coffee that arrives pre-stirred is a warm whiskey milkshake, which is a different and much less interesting thing. The technique depends on two factors: the cream must be cold and only lightly whipped (fully whipped cream is too aerated and will sit as a stiff disc rather than a proper layer), and it must be poured slowly over the back of a spoon rather than dropped directly onto the coffee's surface, which disperses it. Practice this once with a spare cup of coffee before attempting it for guests. It takes about three attempts to get consistently right, and after that it becomes automatic.
On The Whiskey Selection
Bushmills, Jameson, or something with more character. The classic Irish Coffee calls for a blended Irish whiskey rather than a pot still or single malt expression, and there's a good technical reason for this: the drink involves hot liquid, sugar, and cream, all of which mute and compete with subtlety. A complex, expensive whiskey is largely wasted here — its nuances disappear under the coffee and cream, which is a poor use of a good bottle. Bushmills (recommended) is the traditional choice and the one most associated with the drink historically — light, clean, with a gentle honey character that comes through even under coffee and cream. Jameson is the more commonly used option in pubs and produces a very similar result — slightly sweeter, equally reliable. Powers Gold, with its faint pot still character, adds a touch more spice and weight to the finished drink without being wasted the way a premium pot still expression would be. All three work. None of them need to be expensive, and spending more here buys you nothing the coffee and cream won't hide.
Where to have it done properly, if you'd rather not make your own
Swift Soho, on Old Compton Street, makes the benchmark London Irish Coffee — aged Irish whiskey, freshly whipped double cream, a precise amount of sugar, and a float that holds its line from first sip to last. It is the standard against which every other Irish Coffee in the city is measured and, on the evidence of most attempts, found wanting. Worth a detour if you're in Soho and want to see the technique executed without having to do it yourself.
